4 March 1928
Vivian, I gave you children when you didn’t want children. I thought not wanting children was unnatural. You wanted to pursue your acting career and I forced you home with children. I told you, “A woman doesn’t have a career.” You said something like if a woman can vote she can have a career.
You always wanted to prove me wrong. Okay, I was wrong but did you have to prove me wrong this way? Damn it, Vivian–why this way? Why?
When the doctor told me you weren’t strong enough to survive this bleeding, I didn’t want to believe him. You were in a coma. I went in to see you. Your hair that showed under the cap was all matted with sweat. Your face sallow. Your belly flat. The baby dead.
“I don’t want this child, Ed. I have three already. Why can’t I resume my career now?” I remember those words as the life drained from your body this morning.
You came into the bedroom after finding out that a new life was forming inside your soft body. You were furious. You said that I had placed you in a prison and each new child was another bar.
Your brown hair hung straight and your nightgown cast disturbing shadows on the walls. I could only tell you: as soon as your mothering instincts started operating again you would love the idea. That was when you said, “I don’t want this child, Ed…”
I looked down at your comatose face; you didn’t tell me you were going to attempt this. If the man who had found you wasn’t a Samaritan you would have died in that garbage strewn alley. Vivian, weren’t there other solutions? Weren’t there?
September 12, 1930
Harriet, you looked so beautiful tonight by Grant’s lake. The moon in your eyes shone mysteries I will never begin to solve, but that enhanced your beauty.
I have been unfair to you even as I asked you to marry me. I brought you here to City Park because this is where Vivian and I courted. I wanted so desperately to replace her with you and now I know that will never be. Yes. Harriet I love you but my love for you is second to my lover for Vivian. And I shall never have that love again. Are you going to be able to compete with a ghost? I fear not.
I will make it easier for you by not insisting that you be called mother by the children. In that way you will not have to feel that you are replacing Vivian with them. I hope in time you will see the wisdom in this decision.
If this marriage lasts it will be by your determination and love not to allow my past to overshadow the present. It will be the strength of your love that will keep us moving forward. I know this is unfair to you but I don’t know how it can be otherwise. Your love for me will be my salvation.
17 June 1931
Well, I told myself when Vivian died I would never have children again. And now Harriet wants children. I know she didn’t realize it but to ask this day of all days. My anniversary with Vivian, eleven years to the day to tell me she wants children.
No. I will not give Harriet children. I can’t. I won’t. We have children already. Why is it so hard for her to accept them as her own? I’m sure Vivian would have wanted her to accept them in that way.
Vivian, you were a god-send to me. Remember, I met you in City Park back in 1918? I took long walks those days after my mother died.
The day I met you, you were at the peacock cage. Your parasol was twirling to coax one of the peacocks to spread his tail of blue, yellow, and green. And when he finally did after what seemed like hours you laughed with delight, throwing your head back, the sun catching your face and your rich coppery hair. That was when you caught me looking at you.
First you giggled, then you blushed, then you were indignant. You walked over to me to give me a piece of your mind, but before you could; I asked if you wanted to get something to eat. It was noon. You were so shocked, you said yes.
In the years that followed you always talked about Fanny Bryce and Jimmy Durante. How you could’ve been up there in the stars with them. You felt you still could. You and Fanny wrote each other often about the good ol’ days of Vaudeville. But you fell in love with a Bedford Hills man while on tour.
You regretted it, didn’t you? I became the reason for your not reaching stardom. Fanny and Jimmy came to your funeral. They didn’t forget you. I didn’t tell them the facts of your death. I didn’t tell anyone what you had done. It will be our secret.
I wanted you to have my children, Vivian. And now Harriet wants children and I can’t give them to her. She can have your children. Harriet can continue baking angel food cakes for the restaurant. I will not interrupt her career for want of child. Besides, I need her income to help support the mouths we now feed. Blasted Depression. Loosing one wife is payment enough in on lifetime. I don’t want to pay twice.
June 18, 1931
Harriet didn’t speak to me today. I have given her freedom that Vivian didn’t have and she won’t speak to me. How can I tell her what I have done for her?
I feel like a dog being punished for some unmentionable that wasn’t the dog’s fault but the owner’s for not being sensitive enough to the dog’s behavior.
Mother was like that. She acted like Harriet did today. She’d walk around the kitchen, cooking, going from stove to sink to stove to table mixing various ingredients and not saying a word. I wasn’t even in Mother’s line of sight. I would just sit there, watching, wondering if I had done something wrong to receive such oblivious treatment.
I would go over the list of possible wrongs done that might have offended Mother’s good nature. And then I would worry after the list was exhausted fro fear that there could be something new that I didn’t know was wrong. I would start fidgeting, and my palms would sweat so I would wipe them on my knickers. I would fidget some more. Then all my fears were realized, Mother would yell, “Stop your fidgeting! Go do something will you!” At least Mother finally told me what I was doing wrong. Harriet didn’t say a word to me at all.
July 10, 1931
Harriet looked so natural playing with Rose today. No-one would’ve known that they were a step-mother and step-daughter on her fifth birthday. For a minute, I thought that they were my mother and my sister Abigail incarnate. Mother and Abigail played on the same hill behind the house where they played today.
Abigail. I’ve never mentioned her to anyone. How can I talk of someone no-one ever knew; how would anyone understand her? She is my jewel, my memory. As I was remembering, Harriet asked about children again, shattering the moment. Blasted memories they’re as elusive as running water. Once they are secure they become stagnant with bitterness. Do I have to tell her everything? I will not let my jewel be tarnished by soiled hands. I will cherish Abigail’s memory like an heirloom.
Abigail lived to be five years old and she was a happy child. She was always smiling and singing songs to her china dolls dressed in petticoats. When she was five she came down with Scarlet Fever. There wasn’t much we could do. Mother hung sheets petitioning the room from the house. I couldn’t see Abigail. But I remember standing outside the room listening to my mother singing as she wiped my sister’s brow. Softly my mother sang, I’ll walk through the garden alone…” I remember listening to those words she sang and wondering if God was there with you, Abigail, calling you his own. Was that why she left us? Abigail was too beautiful to be ours so God called her home.
When she died all of her clothes were burned and everything had to be cleaned with the most god-awful stuff. The silver utensils she used suffered the most. The stuff turned them black.
Today, I suppose it was the Harriet put daisies in Rose’s hair that reminded me of Abigail. She wore daises all the time. Mother would braid them two abreast and crown Abigail, Princess of the spring. Her golden hair would glimmer in the sun.
Abigail would dance on that hill. And as she danced she would throw up shinleaf and clover into the air. You don’t see shinleaf anymore. There was more shinleaf then than there dandelions. They were all over the place with their white flowers in the summer and red berries in the fall. I guess Abigail picked them all.
May 4, 1933
Seeing my oldest plant those spruces with such determination reminded me of your determined Vivian. I thought it was bull-headedness.
You would be proud of him. He’s planting these trees in your honor. He remembers you and places you on some elusive pedestal to admire and worship. Isn’t that what you wanted from your fans? To be worshipped? Idolized?
Harriet is moved y Robert’s love for you. I am also but I won’t admit to her or to Robert. The pain you afflicted is too great to allow others to tamper it with their mallet.
I know the kind of woman you were and Robert is too young to hear it. Harriet need not know because the past is with the dead and the dying. Since you died, I have been afflicted with the slowest of deaths. And no Balm in Gilead can avert it. Lord knows I tried to find with Harriet what I had with you.
Your death has placed me in a prison. You claim I placed you in one. Only my prison doesn’t have children as bars. My prison has memories that hang like mosquito netting, keeping me from others. I can’t escape them. Now on the side hill is a living tribute to your memory. Although I admire my son’s determination I abhor the symbolism. My prison walls thicken with each tree planted.
August 20, 1939
I went down to the barn to tend to the chickens. I heard some noise so I went to investigate. The hobos often used the barn as a shelter from the damp night. I didn’t care too much as long as they weren’t causing trouble. I turned the corner to the hay stacks and there is the Harrison boy on top of Karl. They’re laughing and giggling like some teenage girls. But they aren’t clothed Vivian. They are rubbing each other down. They were using their tongues on each other’s balls like a dog in heat.
I didn’t know what to do. I was furious. No son of mine was going to be a queer. I had my twenty-two with me in case of vermin after the chickens. I raised my gun and yelled, “You get off my son or I’ll blast you to kingdom come!” Karl and that Harrison boy jumped up.
Karl was all a stammerin’. He looked at me with eyes of fear. I was loosin’ but I had to make my point that this was never going to happen again. I pointed the gun at Harrison and told Karl to get out.
“Karl, they kill queers around here. If you ever decide to screw anything again without two breasts I’ll so much as kill you than look at you, you understand?” Karl ran out of the barn. The Harrison boy just continued to stare at me with that deer in the headlight stare.
The white heat of rage consumed me. I don’t remember what happened next. I found myself in the kitchen washing my hands over and over again. My body was shaking.
The next day, I went down to the barn. There was the Harrison boy swinging in the breeze. I yelled for help. His father came down and claimed the boy’s body. He apologized to me for this happening in our barn. The boy had attempted suicide a few years back. They had thought he had gotten the help he needed because he seemed to be so much better. The doctors weren’t as optimistic.
Karl just stared at me. He stared at me with all the hatred a fifteen year old can have for his father. But Karl is going to be a man because of this Vivian, I just know it.
August 20 1940
Vivian, the barn was torched today. It was falling apart anyway. My father and his father before him farmed this land using that barn. I didn’t use it much, though. We had chickens so Harriet could bake her Angel food cake. The chickens we sold a few months back. That was about it though with the exception of some hay stacks stored there for the Harrison’s’ horse farm up the road.
The blaze was bright. All the people up and down the road came to see what was happening. I told them let it burn, let it burn. It wasn’t going to hurt anybody. I was glad to be rid of it. It was hard to look at anymore. No sense in having a barn if it was just going to rot on its foundation.
People told me they used that barn as a landmark. I guess they’ll just have to find another landmark; this one has used its usefulness.
January 3, 1983
I am leaving this for my children and my children’s children. There are certain events in my life that I have never told anyone. I told myself it was better to forget the old dust bunnies in the closet. I am writing this to clear myself and in regret for any tainted or un-enriched experiences you have had because of me.
My wife Harriet has endured my nonsense without so much of a bat of the eye. I hope that she too can find it in her heart to forgive me. I abused her terribly over these long decades. I wanted to replace the pain in my heart with her presence after Vivian died. Alas Harriet was no Vivian nor should she have been. But it was I who lost out. It has only been recently that I discovered what a gift she truly is. My children have known this gift. I have always been grateful for the love she has shown them as if they were her own, and they have responded in kind.
I did as I wished over these many years. I was king over all I surveyed or so I thought. I didn’t care who I trampled on just so long as I got my way when I wanted it. How foolish I have been.
Harriet, if you should read this journal you will know the man you married was not as I portrayed. I am just a loner with my memories that I could not overcome. I was protective of those memories just like a three year old is protective of his toy and will not share, foolishly thinking that in sharing the memory it somehow becomes not mine any longer, that somehow the memory is tainted by others interpretations and distortions that cannot possibly be valid or real. All along the opposite was true. Withholding memories allows them to embitter the heart, while sharing them no matter how painful frees the heart to step beyond the prison to others.
I have had a lot of time to think about all of this in the recent months since being diagnosed with Lymphoma. How much longer I have is not up to me. I believe my time is coming soon. I have sometimes seen in the morning light Abigail dancing.
Harriet has proven once again her love to me. She stays up with me making sure I am comfortable. She is the saint in this family. She quietly suffered marriage with me with no complaints. I hope Harriet will have it in her heart to forgive me.
Love, Edison.